Show, Don’t Tell: How to Master the Most Important Rule in Storytelling

If you’ve ever spent time in a writing workshop or a critique group, you’ve likely had these three words thrown at you like a mantra: “Show, don’t tell.”

It is perhaps the most famous piece of writing advice in history, famously attributed to the Russian playwright Anton Chekhov, who purportedly said: “Don’t tell me the moon is shining; show me the glint of light on broken glass.”

But while the concept sounds simple, mastering it is what separates amateur prose from professional, immersive storytelling. Let’s break down the science of sensory engagement and how you can use this rule to make your readers feel the story rather than just read it.

1. The Science of Immersion: Why Showing Works

Why does "showing" keep a reader glued to the page while "telling" makes their eyes glaze over? The answer lies in Cognitive Neuroscience.

Research into Mental Simulation (Speer et al., 2009) suggests that when we read sensory-rich descriptions, our brains activate the same regions as if we were experiencing the event in real life. If you write, "He was cold," the reader processes the information intellectually. But if you write, "He pulled his collar up, his breath blooming in the air like pale ghosts," the reader’s brain simulates the sensation of cold.

The "Showing" Effect: You are inviting the reader to be a co-creator. By providing the clues (the breath, the collar), you allow the reader to reach the conclusion ("He’s cold") themselves. This "Aha!" moment creates a much stronger emotional bond with the text.

2. The Hemingway "Iceberg Theory"

To understand the balance of showing and telling, we have to look at Ernest Hemingway. He championed a style called the Iceberg Theory (or the Theory of Omission).

Hemingway believed that the "dignity of movement" of an iceberg is due to only one-eighth of it being above water. In writing, the 1/8th above water is your Showed detail. The 7/8ths underwater is the Told subtext, history, and emotion that the reader feels but doesn't explicitly see on the page.

Getty Images

By only showing the tip of the iceberg, the specific actions and sensory details, you give the reader credit for being smart enough to understand the massive weight of emotion hidden beneath.

3. Turning "Tell" into "Show": A Practical Recipe

Most "telling" happens when writers describe emotions or internal states directly. To fix this, you need to look for Physiological Responses and Action Indicators.

The "Tell" (Abstract)	The "Show" (Concrete)
He was angry.	He gripped the edge of the table until his knuckles turned a bloodless white.
She was nervous.	She checked the time for the fourth time in a minute, her thumb tracing the jagged edge of a chipped fingernail.
The room was messy.	A half-eaten pizza box sat atop a pile of damp laundry, the scent of stale pepperoni mingling with the smell of wet wool.
It was a hot day.	The asphalt shimmered in the distance, and the air felt heavy, like a warm, wet blanket pressed against the face.

Our Tip: Look for "filter words" like felt, saw, noticed, realized, or thought. These words often signal that you are telling the reader about an experience rather than letting them experience it.

• Tell: "I felt the wind get colder."

• Show: "The wind turned sharp, biting through the thin fabric of my coat."

4. The Sensory Toolkit: Beyond Just Sight

Many writers fall into the trap of only "showing" through visual descriptions. To truly master this rule, you must engage the Full Sensory Spectrum.

Research by Dr. Veronique Boulenger (2009) showed that when subjects read action-related metaphors (like "he had leathery hands"), the sensory cortex, not just the language centers, fired up.

• Olfactory (Smell): The smell of rain on hot pavement (Petrichor) or the metallic tang of old coins.

• Tactile (Touch): The grit of sand in a bedsheet or the vibration of a passing train in your teeth.

• Auditory (Sound): The "thrum" of a distant engine or the "hiss" of a closing door.

By mixing these senses, you create a 3D environment that feels "real" because it mimics how humans actually process the world.

5. When to Actually "Tell"

Here is the part most writing guides leave out: Sometimes you MUST tell.

If you "show" every single second of your character’s day—the way they tie their shoes, the exact texture of their breakfast toast, the way the light hits every single leaf on their walk to work, your story will be 2,000 pages long and incredibly boring.

Use "Telling" for:

• Transitions: "Three days passed in a blur of rain." (Don't show three days of rain unless something happens).

• Boring but Necessary Info: "He took the bus to the city center."

• Pacing: Sometimes you need a quick "tell" to move the reader toward the next high-impact "show" scene.

Think of "Showing" as your Slow-Motion Camera for high-drama moments, and "Telling" as your Fast-Forward Button for everything else.

6. Subverting the Cliché with Naming

Since you are a user of The Name Crafter, remember that even a character's name can "show" something about them without you needing to explain it.

• A character named "Sledge" shows strength and bluntness before they even speak.

• A character named "Seraphina" shows a sense of elegance or etherealness.

• 
  

By picking names with the right "mouth-feel" (remember our Bouba/Kiki discussion?), you are showing the reader who this person is through the phonetics of their identity.

Conclusion

"Show, Don't Tell" is not about banning certain words from your vocabulary. It is about trusting your reader. It’s about giving them the "broken glass" and letting them find the moon for themselves.

By focusing on physiological reactions, sensory details, and the "Iceberg" of subtext, you transform your writing from a report into an experience. The next time you see "He felt sad" on your page, stop. Ask yourself: How did that sadness change the way he moved? What did he do with his hands? What did the room look like through his eyes?